desa-darmasaba/QC/PPID/QC-VISI-MISI-PPID-MODULE.md

QC Summary - Visi Misi PPID Module

Scope: Preview Visi Misi, Edit Visi Misi dengan Rich Text Editor
Date: 2026-02-23
Status: ✅ Secara umum sudah baik, ada beberapa improvement yang diperlukan

---

📊 OVERVIEW

Aspect	Schema	API	UI Admin	State Management	Overall
Visi Misi PPID	⚠️ Ada issue	✅ Baik	✅ Baik	✅ Baik	🟡 Perlu fix

---

✅ YANG SUDAH BAIK

1. UI/UX Design

• ✅ Preview layout yang clean dengan logo desa
• ✅ Responsive design (mobile & desktop)
• ✅ Loading states dengan Skeleton
• ✅ Empty state handling yang informatif
• ✅ Edit button yang prominent
• ✅ Divider visual yang jelas antara Visi dan Misi

2. Rich Text Editor (Tiptap)

• ✅ Full-featured editor dengan toolbar lengkap
• ✅ Extensions: Bold, Italic, Underline, Highlight, Link, dll
• ✅ Text alignment (left, center, justify, right)
• ✅ Heading levels (H1-H4)
• ✅ Lists (bullet & ordered)
• ✅ Blockquote, code, superscript, subscript
• ✅ Undo/Redo
• ✅ Sticky toolbar untuk UX yang lebih baik
• ✅ immediatelyRender: false untuk menghindari hydration mismatch

3. Form Component Structure

• ✅ Modular form components (VisiPPID, MisiPPID)
• ✅ Reusable PPIDTextEditor component
• ✅ Proper TypeScript typing
• ✅ Controlled components dengan onChange handler

4. State Management

• ✅ Proper typing dengan Prisma types
• ✅ Loading state management dengan finally block
• ✅ Error handling yang comprehensive
• ✅ ApiFetch consistency - Semua operasi pakai ApiFetch! ✅
• ✅ Zod validation untuk form data

Code Example (✅ EXCELLENT):

// state file - Line ~30-50
findById: {
  data: null as VisiMisiPPIDForm | null,
  loading: false,
  initialize() {
    stateVisiMisiPPID.findById.data = {
      id: "",
      misi: "",
      visi: "",
    } as VisiMisiPPIDForm;
  },
  async load(id: string) {
    try {
      stateVisiMisiPPID.findById.loading = true; // ✅ Start loading
      const res = await ApiFetch.api.ppid.visimisippid["find-by-id"].get({
        query: { id },
      });
      if (res.status === 200) {
        stateVisiMisiPPID.findById.data = res.data?.data ?? null;
      }
    } catch (error) {
      console.error((error as Error).message);
      toast.error("Terjadi kesalahan saat mengambil data visi misi");
    } finally {
      stateVisiMisiPPID.findById.loading = false; // ✅ Stop loading
    }
  },
}

Verdict: ✅ SANGAT BAIK - State management sudah konsisten dengan ApiFetch!

---

5. Edit Form - Original Data Tracking

• ✅ Original data state untuk reset form
• ✅ Load data existing dengan benar
• ✅ Reset form mengembalikan ke data original
• ✅ Rich text content handling yang proper

Code Example (✅ GOOD):

// edit/page.tsx - Line ~20-45
const [formData, setFormData] = useState({ visi: '', misi: '' });
const [originalData, setOriginalData] = useState({ visi: '', misi: '' });

// Initialize from global state
useEffect(() => {
  if (visiMisi.findById.data) {
    setFormData({
      visi: visiMisi.findById.data.visi ?? '',
      misi: visiMisi.findById.data.misi ?? '',
    });
    setOriginalData({
      visi: visiMisi.findById.data.visi ?? '',
      misi: visiMisi.findById.data.misi ?? '',
    });
  }
}, [visiMisi.findById.data]);

// Line ~60 - Handle reset
const handleResetForm = () => {
  setFormData({
    visi: originalData.visi,
    misi: originalData.misi,
  });
  toast.info('Form dikembalikan ke data awal');
};

Verdict: ✅ BAIK - Original data tracking sudah implementasi dengan baik!

---

6. Rich Text Validation

• ✅ Custom validation function untuk rich text content
• ✅ Check empty content setelah remove HTML tags

Code Example (✅ GOOD):

// edit/page.tsx - Line ~25-35
const isRichTextEmpty = (content: string) => {
  // Remove HTML tags and check if the resulting text is empty
  const plainText = content.replace(/<[^>]*>/g, '').trim();
  return plainText === '' || content.trim() === '<p></p>' || content.trim() === '<p><br></p>';
};

const isFormValid = () => {
  return (
    !isRichTextEmpty(formData.visi) &&
    !isRichTextEmpty(formData.misi)
  );
};

Verdict: ✅ EXCELLENT - Rich text validation yang comprehensive!

---

⚠️ ISSUES & SARAN PERBAIKAN

🔴 CRITICAL

1. Schema - deletedAt Default Value SALAH

Lokasi: prisma/schema.prisma (line 374)

Masalah:

model VisiMisiPPID {
  id        String   @id @default(cuid())
  visi      String   @db.Text
  misi      String   @db.Text
  createdAt DateTime @default(now())
  updatedAt DateTime @updatedAt
  deletedAt DateTime  @default(now())  // ❌ SALAH - selalu punya default value
  isActive  Boolean  @default(true)
}

Dampak:

• LOGIC ERROR! Setiap record baru langsung punya deletedAt value (timestamp creation)
• Soft delete tidak berfungsi dengan benar
• Query dengan where: { deletedAt: null } tidak akan pernah return data
• Data yang "dihapus" vs data "aktif" tidak bisa dibedakan

Contoh Issue:

// Record baru dibuat
CREATE VisiMisiPPID {
  visi: "Visi 1",
  misi: "Misi 1",
  // deletedAt otomatis ter-set ke now() ❌
  // isActive: true ✅
}

// Query untuk data aktif (seharusnya return data ini)
prisma.visiMisiPPID.findMany({
  where: { deletedAt: null, isActive: true }
})
// ❌ Return kosong! Karena deletedAt sudah ter-set

Rekomendasi: Fix schema:

model VisiMisiPPID {
  id        String    @id @default(cuid())
  visi      String    @db.Text
  misi      String    @db.Text
  createdAt DateTime  @default(now())
  updatedAt DateTime  @updatedAt
  deletedAt DateTime? @default(null)  // ✅ Nullable, null = not deleted
  isActive  Boolean   @default(true)
}

Priority: 🔴 CRITICAL
Effort: Medium (perlu migration)
Impact: HIGH (data integrity & soft delete logic)

---

2. HTML Injection Risk - dangerouslySetInnerHTML

Lokasi: page.tsx (preview page)

Masalah:

// Line ~85-95
<Text
  ta={{ base: "center", md: "justify" }}
  dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: listVisiMisi.findById.data.visi }}  // ❌ No sanitization
  style={{ ... }}
/>

// Line ~105-115 (Misi)
<Text
  ta={"justify"}
  dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: listVisiMisi.findById.data.misi }}  // ❌ No sanitization
  style={{ ... }}
/>

Risk:

• XSS attack jika admin input script malicious
• Bisa inject iframe, script tag, dll
• Security vulnerability

Rekomendasi: Gunakan DOMPurify atau library sanitization:

import DOMPurify from 'dompurify';

// Sanitize sebelum render
const sanitizedVisi = DOMPurify.sanitize(listVisiMisi.findById.data.visi);
const sanitizedMisi = DOMPurify.sanitize(listVisiMisi.findById.data.misi);

<Text
  dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: sanitizedVisi }}
  // ...
/>

Atau validasi di backend untuk whitelist tag HTML yang diperbolehkan (hanya <p>, <ul>, <li>, <strong>, dll).

Priority: 🔴 HIGH (Security concern)
Effort: Low

---

3. Missing Delete/Hard Delete Protection

Lokasi: page.tsx, edit/page.tsx

Masalah:

• ❌ Tidak ada tombol delete untuk Visi Misi (correct - single record)
• ✅ GOOD: Single record pattern yang benar
• ⚠️ ISSUE: Tidak ada konfirmasi sebelum update (direct save)

Issue: User bisa accidentally save changes tanpa konfirmasi.

Rekomendasi: Add confirmation dialog sebelum save:

const submit = () => {
  // Check if data has changed
  if (formData.visi === originalData.visi && formData.misi === originalData.misi) {
    toast.info('Tidak ada perubahan');
    return;
  }

  // Show confirmation
  const confirmed = window.confirm('Apakah Anda yakin ingin mengubah Visi Misi PPID?');
  if (!confirmed) return;

  // Then save...
};

Priority: 🔴 Medium
Effort: Low

---

🟡 MEDIUM

4. Console.log di Production

Lokasi: src/app/admin/(dashboard)/_state/ppid/visi_misi_ppid/visimisiPPID.ts

Masalah:

// Line ~40
console.error((error as Error).message);

// Line ~65
console.error((error as Error).message);

Rekomendasi: Gunakan conditional logging:

if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development') {
  console.error("Error:", error);
}

Priority: 🟡 Low
Effort: Low

---

5. Missing Loading State di Submit Button

Lokasi: edit/page.tsx

Masalah:

// Line ~120-130
<Button
  onClick={submit}
  radius="md"
  size="md"
  disabled={!isFormValid() || isSubmitting}
  // ...
>
  {isSubmitting ? <Loader size="sm" color="white" /> : 'Simpan'}
</Button>

Issue: Button tidak check visiMisi.update.loading dari global state.

Rekomendasi: Check both states:

disabled={!isFormValid() || isSubmitting || visiMisi.update.loading}
{isSubmitting || visiMisi.update.loading ? (
  <Loader size="sm" color="white" />
) : (
  'Simpan'
)}

Priority: 🟡 Low
Effort: Low

---

6. Zod Schema - Could Be More Specific

Lokasi: src/app/admin/(dashboard)/_state/ppid/visi_misi_ppid/visimisiPPID.ts

Masalah:

// Line ~7
const templateForm = z.object({
  misi: z.string().min(3, "Misi minimal 3 karakter"), // ⚠️ Generic
  visi: z.string().min(3, "Visi minimal 3 karakter"), // ⚠️ Generic
});

Rekomendasi: More specific error messages:

const templateForm = z.object({
  misi: z.string().min(3, "Misi PPID minimal 3 karakter"),
  visi: z.string().min(3, "Visi PPID minimal 3 karakter"),
});

Priority: 🟡 Low
Effort: Low

---

🟢 LOW (Minor Polish)

7. Missing Change Detection

Lokasi: edit/page.tsx

Masalah:

// Line ~70-80
const submit = () => {
  try {
    setIsSubmitting(true);
    if (visiMisi.findById.data) {
      // update nilai global hanya saat submit
      visiMisi.findById.data.visi = formData.visi;
      visiMisi.findById.data.misi = formData.misi;
      visiMisi.update.save(visiMisi.findById.data);
    }
    router.push('/admin/ppid/visi-misi-ppid');
  } catch (error) {
    console.error("Error updating visi misi:", error);
    toast.error("Terjadi kesalahan saat memperbarui visi misi");
  } finally {
    setIsSubmitting(false);
  }
};

Issue: Tidak ada check apakah data sudah berubah. User bisa save tanpa perubahan.

Rekomendasi: Add change detection:

const submit = () => {
  // Check if data has changed
  if (formData.visi === originalData.visi && formData.misi === originalData.misi) {
    toast.info('Tidak ada perubahan');
    return;
  }

  try {
    setIsSubmitting(true);
    // ... rest of save logic
  }
};

Priority: 🟢 Low
Effort: Low

---

8. Editor - Duplicate useEffect

Lokasi: PPIDTextEditor.tsx

Masalah:

// Line ~30-35
const editor = useEditor({
  extensions: [...],
  immediatelyRender: false,
  content: initialContent, // ✅ Set content directly
  onUpdate: ({editor}) => {
    onChange(editor.getHTML()) // ✅ Handle changes
  }
});

// Line ~37-42
useEffect(() => {
  if (editor && initialContent !== editor.getHTML()) {
    editor.commands.setContent(initialContent || '<p></p>');
  }
}, [initialContent, editor]);

Issue: Ada useEffect tambahan untuk set content, padahal sudah ada di useEditor. Bisa menyebabkan double content update.

Rekomendasi: Simplify - remove useEffect:

const editor = useEditor({
  extensions: [...],
  immediatelyRender: false,
  content: initialContent || '<p></p>', // ✅ Set content directly
  onUpdate: ({editor}) => {
    onChange(editor.getHTML())
  },
  editorProps: {
    // Optional: handle content updates better
  }
});

// Remove useEffect completely

Priority: 🟢 Low
Effort: Low

---

9. Missing Error Boundary

Lokasi: edit/page.tsx

Masalah:

• Tidak ada error boundary untuk handle unexpected errors
• Jika editor gagal load, tidak ada fallback UI

Rekomendasi: Add error boundary:

if (visiMisi.findById.error) {
  return (
    <Alert icon={<IconAlertCircle />} color="red">
      <Text fw="bold">Error</Text>
      <Text>{visiMisi.findById.error}</Text>
    </Alert>
  );
}

Priority: 🟢 Low
Effort: Low

---

10. Preview Page - Hardcoded Moto PPID

Lokasi: page.tsx

Masalah:

// Line ~60-70
<Text
  ta="center"
  fz={{ base: 'sm', md: 'md' }}
  lh={{ base: 1.5, md: 1.5 }}
  mt="sm"
  c="black"
>
  MEMBERIKAN INFORMASI YANG CEPAT, MUDAH, TEPAT DAN TRANSPARAN
</Text>

Issue: Moto PPID hardcoded di UI. Seharusnya dari database/config.

Rekomendasi: Move to database or config file:

// Add to schema
model VisiMisiPPID {
  // ...
  moto String? @db.Text
}

// Or use config
const PPID_MOTO = "MEMBERIKAN INFORMASI YANG CEPAT, MUDAH, TEPAT DAN TRANSPARAN";

Priority: 🟢 Low
Effort: Medium (perlu schema change)

---

11. Title Order Inconsistency

Lokasi: page.tsx

Masalah:

// Line ~45
<Title order={3} ...>Preview Visi Misi PPID</Title>

// Line ~65
<Title order={2} ...>MOTO PPID DESA DARMASABA</Title>

// Line ~80
<Title order={2} ...>VISI PPID</Title>

// Line ~100
<Title order={2} ...>MISI PPID</Title>

Issue: Title hierarchy agak confusing. Page title (order 3) lebih kecil dari section titles (order 2).

Rekomendasi: Samakan hierarchy:

// Page title: order={2}
// Section titles: order={3}

Priority: 🟢 Low
Effort: Low

---

12. Missing Toast Success After Save

Lokasi: edit/page.tsx

Masalah:

// Line ~70-85
const submit = () => {
  try {
    setIsSubmitting(true);
    if (visiMisi.findById.data) {
      visiMisi.findById.data.visi = formData.visi;
      visiMisi.findById.data.misi = formData.misi;
      visiMisi.update.save(visiMisi.findById.data);
    }
    router.push('/admin/ppid/visi-misi-ppid');  // ✅ Redirect tanpa toast
  } catch (error) {
    console.error("Error updating visi misi:", error);
    toast.error("Terjadi kesalahan saat memperbarui visi misi");
  } finally {
    setIsSubmitting(false);
  }
};

Issue: Toast success ada di state update.save(), tapi user mungkin tidak lihat karena langsung redirect.

Rekomendasi: Add toast before redirect atau wait untuk toast selesai:

const submit = async () => {
  try {
    setIsSubmitting(true);
    if (visiMisi.findById.data) {
      visiMisi.findById.data.visi = formData.visi;
      visiMisi.findById.data.misi = formData.misi;
      await visiMisi.update.save(visiMisi.findById.data);
      toast.success("Visi Misi berhasil diperbarui!");
      setTimeout(() => {
        router.push('/admin/ppid/visi-misi-ppid');
      }, 1000); // Wait 1 second for toast to show
    }
  } catch (error) {
    console.error("Error updating visi misi:", error);
    toast.error("Terjadi kesalahan saat memperbarui visi misi");
  } finally {
    setIsSubmitting(false);
  }
};

Priority: 🟢 Low
Effort: Low

---

📋 RINGKASAN ACTION ITEMS

Priority	Issue	Module	Impact	Effort	Status
🔴 P0	Schema deletedAt default SALAH	Schema	CRITICAL	Medium	MUST FIX
🔴 P0	HTML injection risk	UI	HIGH (Security)	Low	Should fix
🔴 P1	Missing delete confirmation	UI	Medium	Low	Should fix
🟡 M	Console.log in production	State	Low	Low	Optional
🟡 M	Missing loading state di submit button	UI	Low	Low	Should fix
🟡 M	Zod schema error messages	State	Low	Low	Optional
🟢 L	Missing change detection	Edit UI	Low	Low	Optional
🟢 L	Duplicate useEffect di editor	Editor	Low	Low	Optional
🟢 L	Missing error boundary	UI	Low	Low	Optional
🟢 L	Hardcoded Moto PPID	UI	Low	Medium	Optional
🟢 L	Title order inconsistency	UI	Low	Low	Optional
🟢 L	Missing toast success timing	UI	Low	Low	Optional

---

✅ KESIMPULAN

Overall Quality: 🟢 BAIK (8.5/10) - CLEANEST MODULE!

Strengths:

1. ✅ UI/UX clean & responsive
2. ✅ Rich Text Editor full-featured (Tiptap)
3. ✅ Modular form components (Visi, Misi)
4. ✅ State management BEST PRACTICES - ONLY MODULE YANG 100% ApiFetch! ✅
5. ✅ Edit form reset sudah benar (original data tracking)
6. ✅ Rich text validation comprehensive (check empty content)
7. ✅ Error handling comprehensive
8. ✅ Loading state management dengan finally block
9. ✅ immediatelyRender: false untuk menghindari hydration mismatch

Critical Issues:

1. ⚠️ Schema deletedAt default SALAH - Logic error untuk soft delete (CRITICAL)
2. ⚠️ HTML injection risk - dangerouslySetInnerHTML tanpa sanitization (HIGH Security)
3. ⚠️ Missing confirmation sebelum save (Medium UX)

Areas for Improvement:

1. ⚠️ Fix schema deletedAt dari @default(now()) ke @default(null) dengan nullable
2. ⚠️ Fix HTML injection dengan DOMPurify atau backend validation
3. ⚠️ Add confirmation dialog sebelum save
4. ⚠️ Add change detection untuk avoid unnecessary saves
5. ⚠️ Fix loading state di submit button

Recommended Next Steps:

1. 🔴 CRITICAL: Fix schema deletedAt - 30 menit (perlu migration)
2. 🔴 HIGH: Fix HTML injection dengan DOMPurify - 30 menit
3. 🟡 MEDIUM: Add confirmation dialog - 15 menit
4. 🟢 LOW: Add change detection - 15 menit
5. 🟢 LOW: Polish minor issues - 30 menit

---

📈 COMPARISON WITH OTHER MODULES

Module	Fetch Pattern	State	Edit Reset	Rich Text	HTML Injection	deletedAt	Overall
Profil	⚠️ Mixed	⚠️ Good	✅ Good	❌ None	⚠️ Present	⚠️ Issue	🟢
Desa Anti Korupsi	⚠️ Mixed	⚠️ Good	✅ Good	✅ Present	⚠️ Present	⚠️ Issue	🟢
SDGs Desa	⚠️ Mixed	⚠️ Good	✅ Good	❌ None	N/A	⚠️ Issue	🟢
APBDes	⚠️ Mixed	⚠️ Good	✅ Good	❌ None	N/A	✅ Good	🟢
Prestasi Desa	⚠️ Mixed	⚠️ Good	✅ Good	✅ Present	⚠️ Present	❌ WRONG	🟢
PPID Profil	⚠️ Mixed	✅ Best	✅ Excellent	✅ Best	⚠️ Present	❌ WRONG	🟢⭐
Struktur PPID	⚠️ Mixed	✅ Good	✅ Good	✅ Present	⚠️ Present	⚠️ Inconsistent	🟢
Visi Misi PPID	✅ 100% ApiFetch!	✅ Best	✅ Good	✅ Present	⚠️ Present	❌ WRONG	🟢⭐⭐

Visi Misi PPID Highlights:

• ✅ ONLY MODULE yang 100% konsisten pakai ApiFetch! (NO fetch manual!)
• ✅ CLEANEST CODE - Simple, straightforward, no complexity
• ✅ Rich text validation paling comprehensive (check empty content)
• ✅ Best state management pattern (ApiFetch consistency)
• ⚠️ Same deletedAt issue seperti modul PPID lain

---

🎯 UNIQUE FEATURES OF VISI MISI PPID MODULE

Simplest & Cleanest Module:

1. ✅ 100% ApiFetch consistency - NO fetch manual sama sekali! (UNIQUE!)
2. ✅ Simple single record pattern - Only 2 fields (visi, misi)
3. ✅ Rich text validation - Check empty content after remove HTML tags
4. ✅ Modular editor components - VisiPPID, MisiPPID separate
5. ✅ No file upload - Simplest form (text only)

Best Practices:

1. ✅ ApiFetch 100% - Best practice untuk API consistency
2. ✅ Loading state management proper (dengan finally block)
3. ✅ Rich text validation comprehensive
4. ✅ Original data tracking untuk reset form
5. ✅ immediatelyRender: false - Avoid hydration mismatch

Critical Issues:

1. ❌ Schema deletedAt SALAH - Same issue seperti modul PPID lain
2. ❌ HTML injection risk - Same issue seperti modul dengan rich text lain

---

Catatan: Visi Misi PPID adalah MODULE PALING CLEAN dengan codebase paling simple dan SATU-SATUNYA MODULE YANG 100% PAKAI ApiFetch (no fetch manual sama sekali!). Module ini bisa jadi REFERENCE untuk API consistency!

Unique Strengths:

1. ✅ 100% ApiFetch - Best API consistency (NO fetch manual!)
2. ✅ Simple & clean - No unnecessary complexity
3. ✅ Rich text validation - Most comprehensive
4. ✅ Best state management pattern

Priority Action:

🔴 FIX INI SEKARANG (30 MENIT + MIGRATION):
File: prisma/schema.prisma
Line: 374

model VisiMisiPPID {
  id        String    @id @default(cuid())
  visi      String    @db.Text
  misi      String    @db.Text
  createdAt DateTime  @default(now())
  updatedAt DateTime  @updatedAt
- deletedAt DateTime  @default(now())
+ deletedAt DateTime? @default(null)
  isActive  Boolean   @default(true)
}

# Lalu jalankan:
bunx prisma db push
# atau
bunx prisma migrate dev --name fix_deletedat_visimisi_ppid

🔴 FIX HTML INJECTION (30 MENIT):
File: page.tsx
+ import DOMPurify from 'dompurify';

// Line ~85
- dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: listVisiMisi.findById.data.visi }}
+ dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: DOMPurify.sanitize(listVisiMisi.findById.data.visi) }}

// Line ~105
- dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: listVisiMisi.findById.data.misi }}
+ dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: DOMPurify.sanitize(listVisiMisi.findById.data.misi) }}

Setelah fix critical issues, module ini PRODUCTION-READY dan bisa jadi REFERENCE untuk API CONSISTENCY! 🎉

---

📚 RECOMMENDED AS REFERENCE FOR OTHER MODULES

Visi Misi PPID Module adalah BEST PRACTICE untuk:

1. ✅ API consistency - 100% ApiFetch, NO fetch manual!
2. ✅ Simple state management - Clean, straightforward
3. ✅ Rich text validation - Check empty content pattern
4. ✅ Modular editor components - Separate Visi & Misi

Modules lain bisa belajar dari Visi Misi PPID:

• ALL MODULES: Use ApiFetch consistently (NO fetch manual!)
• ALL MODULES: Keep it simple (avoid unnecessary complexity)
• Rich Text Modules: Implement empty content validation
• ALL MODULES: Proper loading state management

---

File Location: QC/PPID/QC-VISI-MISI-PPID-MODULE.md 📄