# QC Summary - Struktur PPID Module

**Scope:** Struktur Organisasi (Organization Chart), Pegawai PPID, Posisi Organisasi  
**Date:** 2026-02-23  
**Status:** ✅ Secara umum sudah baik, ada beberapa improvement yang diperlukan

---

## 📊 OVERVIEW

| Sub-Module | Schema | API | UI Admin | State Management | Overall |
|------------|--------|-----|----------|-----------------|---------|
| Struktur Organisasi | ✅ Baik | ✅ Baik | ✅ **Excellent** | ✅ Baik | 🟢 |
| Posisi Organisasi | ⚠️ Ada issue | ✅ Baik | ✅ Baik | ⚠️ Ada issue | 🟡 |
| Pegawai PPID | ⚠️ Ada issue | ✅ Baik | ✅ Baik | ⚠️ Ada issue | 🟡 |

---

## ✅ YANG SUDAH BAIK

### **1. UI/UX - Organization Chart (UNIQUE FEATURE!)**
- ✅ **PrimeReact OrganizationChart** - Visual hierarchy yang excellent
- ✅ Interactive tree structure dengan expand/collapse
- ✅ Custom node template dengan foto, nama, dan posisi
- ✅ Responsive design dengan overflow handling
- ✅ Empty state yang informatif
- ✅ Loading state dengan spinner

**Code Example (✅ EXCELLENT):**
```typescript
// struktur-organisasi/page.tsx - Line ~45-75
const posisiMap = new Map<string, any>();

const aktifPegawai = stateOrganisasi.findManyAll.data?.filter(p => p.isActive);

for (const pegawai of aktifPegawai) {
  const posisiId = pegawai.posisi.id;
  if (!posisiMap.has(posisiId)) {
    posisiMap.set(posisiId, {
      ...pegawai.posisi,
      pegawaiList: [],
      children: [],
    });
  }
  posisiMap.get(posisiId)!.pegawaiList.push(pegawai);
}

// Build tree structure
let root: any[] = [];
posisiMap.forEach((posisi) => {
  if (posisi.parentId) {
    const parent = posisiMap.get(posisi.parentId);
    if (parent) {
      parent.children.push(posisi);
    }
  } else {
    root.push(posisi);
  }
});

// Convert to OrganizationChart format
function toOrgChartFormat(node: any): any {
  return {
    expanded: true,
    type: 'person',
    styleClass: 'p-person',
    data: {
      name: node.pegawaiList?.[0]?.namaLengkap || 'Belum ada pegawai',
      status: node.nama,
      image: node.pegawaiList?.[0]?.image?.link || '/img/default.png',
    },
    children: node.children.map(toOrgChartFormat),
  };
}
```

**Verdict:** ✅ **UNIQUE & EXCELLENT** - Satu-satunya modul dengan organization chart visual!

---

### **2. File Upload Handling**
- ✅ Dropzone dengan preview image
- ✅ Validasi format gambar (JPEG, JPG, PNG, WEBP)
- ✅ Validasi ukuran file (max 5MB)
- ✅ Tombol hapus preview (IconX di pojok kanan atas)
- ✅ URL.createObjectURL untuk preview lokal

### **3. Form Validation**
- ✅ Zod schema untuk validasi typed
- ✅ Email validation dengan regex
- ✅ Required field validation
- ✅ isFormValid() check sebelum submit
- ✅ Error toast dengan pesan spesifik
- ✅ Button disabled saat invalid/loading

### **4. CRUD Operations**
- ✅ Create dengan upload file
- ✅ FindMany dengan pagination & search
- ✅ FindUnique untuk detail
- ✅ Delete dengan hard delete
- ✅ Update dengan file replacement
- ✅ **Non-active feature** untuk soft disable pegawai

### **5. State Management**
- ✅ Proper typing dengan Prisma types
- ✅ Loading state management dengan finally block
- ✅ Error handling yang comprehensive
- ✅ Reset function untuk cleanup
- ✅ findManyAll untuk organization chart data

**Code Example (✅ GOOD):**
```typescript
// state file - Line ~270-290
findManyAll: {
  data: null as Prisma.PegawaiPPIDGetPayload<{...}>[] | null,
  loading: false,
  search: "",
  load: async (search = "") => {
    posisiOrganisasi.findManyAll.loading = true; // ✅ Start loading
    posisiOrganisasi.findManyAll.search = search;
    try {
      const query: any = { search };
      if (search) query.search = search;

      const res = await ApiFetch.api.ppid.strukturppid.pegawai["find-many-all"].get({ query });

      if (res.status === 200 && res.data?.success) {
        posisiOrganisasi.findManyAll.data = res.data.data || [];
      }
    } catch (error) {
      console.error("Error loading pegawai:", error);
      posisiOrganisasi.findManyAll.data = [];
    } finally {
      posisiOrganisasi.findManyAll.loading = false; // ✅ Stop loading
    }
  },
}
```

**Verdict:** ✅ **BAIK** - Loading state management sudah proper!

---

### **6. Edit Form - Original Data Tracking**
- ✅ Original data state untuk reset form
- ✅ Load data existing dengan benar
- ✅ Preview image dari data lama
- ✅ Reset form mengembalikan ke data original
- ✅ File replacement logic (upload baru jika ada perubahan)

**Code Example (✅ GOOD):**
```typescript
// edit/page.tsx - Line ~80-115
const [originalData, setOriginalData] = useState({
  namaLengkap: "",
  gelarAkademik: "",
  imageId: "",
  tanggalMasuk: "",
  email: "",
  telepon: "",
  alamat: "",
  posisiId: "",
  imageUrl: "",
  isActive: true,
});

// Load data
const data = await stateOrganisasi.edit.load(id);

setOriginalData({
  ...data,
  imageUrl: data.image?.link || '',
});

setPreviewImage(data.image?.link || null);

// Line ~135 - Handle reset
const handleResetForm = () => {
  setFormData({
    namaLengkap: originalData.namaLengkap,
    gelarAkademik: originalData.gelarAkademik,
    imageId: originalData.imageId,
    tanggalMasuk: originalData.tanggalMasuk,
    email: originalData.email,
    telepon: originalData.telepon,
    alamat: originalData.alamat,
    posisiId: originalData.posisiId,
    isActive: originalData.isActive,
  });
  setPreviewImage(originalData.imageUrl || null);
  setFile(null);
  toast.info("Form dikembalikan ke data awal");
};
```

**Verdict:** ✅ **BAIK** - Original data tracking sudah implementasi dengan baik!

---

### **7. Unique Features**
- ✅ **Organization Chart** - Visual hierarchy tree (UNIQUE!)
- ✅ **Hierarchical Positions** - Parent-child relationships
- ✅ **Active/Non-active Toggle** - Soft disable untuk pegawai
- ✅ **Email Validation** - Regex validation untuk email format
- ✅ **Date Input Handling** - Proper date formatting untuk tanggal masuk

---

## ⚠️ ISSUES & SARAN PERBAIKAN

### **🔴 CRITICAL**

#### **1. Schema - Missing deletedAt for Soft Delete**

**Lokasi:** `prisma/schema.prisma` (line 327-332, 343-351)

**Masalah:**
```prisma
model PosisiOrganisasiPPID {
  // ...
  isActive  Boolean  @default(true)
  createdAt DateTime @default(now())
  updatedAt DateTime @updatedAt
  // ❌ MISSING: deletedAt field untuk soft delete
}

model PegawaiPPID {
  // ...
  isActive  Boolean  @default(true)
  createdAt DateTime @default(now())
  updatedAt DateTime @updatedAt
  // ❌ MISSING: deletedAt field untuk soft delete
}
```

**Dampak:**
- **INCONSISTENT!** Model `StrukturOrganisasiPPID` punya `deletedAt`, tapi Posisi dan Pegawai tidak
- Hard delete vs soft delete inconsistency
- Data integrity issue saat delete (data hilang permanen)
- Tidak bisa restore data yang ter-delete

**Rekomendasi:** Add deletedAt field:
```prisma
model PosisiOrganisasiPPID {
  // ...
  isActive   Boolean    @default(true)
  createdAt  DateTime   @default(now())
  updatedAt  DateTime   @updatedAt
  deletedAt  DateTime?  @default(null)  // ✅ Add for soft delete
}

model PegawaiPPID {
  // ...
  isActive   Boolean    @default(true)
  createdAt  DateTime   @default(now())
  updatedAt  DateTime   @updatedAt
  deletedAt  DateTime?  @default(null)  // ✅ Add for soft delete
}
```

**Priority:** 🔴 **HIGH**  
**Effort:** Medium (perlu migration)  
**Impact:** **HIGH** (data integrity & consistency)

---

#### **2. State Management - Fetch Pattern Inconsistency**

**Lokasi:** `src/app/admin/(dashboard)/_state/ppid/struktur_ppid/struktur_PPID.ts`

**Masalah:** Ada 2 pattern berbeda untuk fetch API:

```typescript
// ❌ Pattern 1: ApiFetch (create, findMany, findManyAll)
const res = await ApiFetch.api.ppid.strukturppid.pegawai["create"].post(pegawai.create.form);
const res = await ApiFetch.api.ppid.strukturppid.pegawai["find-many"].get({ query });
const res = await ApiFetch.api.ppid.strukturppid.pegawai["find-many-all"].get({ query });

// ❌ Pattern 2: fetch manual (findUnique, edit, delete, nonActive)
const res = await fetch(`/api/ppid/strukturppid/pegawai/${id}`);
const res = await fetch(`/api/ppid/strukturppid/pegawai/del/${id}`, { method: "DELETE" });
const res = await fetch(`/api/ppid/strukturppid/pegawai/non-active/${id}`, { method: "DELETE" });
```

**Dampak:**
- Code consistency buruk
- Sulit maintenance
- Type safety tidak konsisten
- Duplikasi logic error handling

**Rekomendasi:** Gunakan **ApiFetch** untuk semua operasi:

```typescript
// ✅ Unified pattern
async load(id: string) {
  try {
    const res = await ApiFetch.api.ppid.strukturppid.pegawai[id].get();
    
    if (res.data?.success) {
      const data = res.data.data;
      this.id = data.id;
      this.form = {
        namaLengkap: data.namaLengkap,
        gelarAkademik: data.gelarAkademik,
        imageId: data.imageId,
        tanggalMasuk: data.tanggalMasuk,
        email: data.email,
        telepon: data.telepon,
        alamat: data.alamat,
        posisiId: data.posisiId,
        isActive: data.isActive,
      };
      return data;
    } else {
      throw new Error(res.data?.message || "Gagal memuat data");
    }
  } catch (error) {
    console.error("Error loading pegawai:", error);
    toast.error(error instanceof Error ? error.message : "Gagal memuat data");
    return null;
  }
}

async byId(id: string) {
  try {
    const res = await ApiFetch.api.ppid.strukturppid.pegawai["del"][id].delete();
    
    if (res.data?.success) {
      toast.success(res.data.message || "Berhasil hapus pegawai");
      await pegawai.findMany.load();
    } else {
      toast.error(res.data?.message || "Gagal hapus pegawai");
    }
  } catch (error) {
    console.error("Gagal delete:", error);
    toast.error("Terjadi kesalahan saat menghapus");
  }
}
```

**Priority:** 🔴 High  
**Effort:** Medium (refactor di semua methods)

---

#### **3. HTML Injection Risk - dangerouslySetInnerHTML**

**Lokasi:** 
- `posisi-organisasi/page.tsx` (line ~95, 155)
- `posisi-organisasi/create/page.tsx` (CreateEditor component)
- `posisi-organisasi/[id]/edit/page.tsx` (EditEditor component)

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// ❌ Direct HTML render tanpa sanitization
<Text
  fz="sm"
  lh={1.5}
  c="dimmed"
  lineClamp={1}
  dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: item.deskripsi || '-' }}
/>
```

**Risk:**
- XSS attack jika admin input script malicious
- Bisa inject iframe, script tag, dll
- Security vulnerability

**Rekomendasi:** Gunakan DOMPurify atau library sanitization:

```typescript
import DOMPurify from 'dompurify';

// Sanitize sebelum render
const sanitizedDeskripsi = DOMPurify.sanitize(item.deskripsi);
<Text
  dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: sanitizedDeskripsi }}
  // ...
/>
```

Atau validasi di backend untuk whitelist tag HTML yang diperbolehkan.

**Priority:** 🔴 **HIGH** (**Security concern**)  
**Effort:** Low

---

### **🟡 MEDIUM**

#### **4. Console.log di Production**

**Lokasi:** Multiple places di state file

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// Line ~65
console.error("Load struktur error:", errorMessage);

// Line ~130
console.error("Update struktur error:", errorMessage);

// Line ~220
console.error("Failed to fetch posisiOrganisasi:", res.statusText);

// Line ~224
console.error("Error fetching posisiOrganisasi:", error);

// Line ~370
console.error("Gagal fetch posisi organisasi paginated:", err);

// Line ~400
console.error("Failed to load posisiOrganisasi:", res.data?.message);

// Line ~404
console.error("Error loading posisiOrganisasi:", error);

// ... dan banyak lagi
```

**Rekomendasi:** Gunakan conditional logging:

```typescript
if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development') {
  console.error("Error:", error);
}
```

**Priority:** 🟡 Low  
**Effort:** Low

---

#### **5. Type Safety - Any Usage**

**Lokasi:** `src/app/admin/(dashboard)/_state/ppid/struktur_ppid/struktur_PPID.ts`

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// Line ~190
const query: any = { page, limit: appliedLimit }; // ❌ Using 'any'
if (search) query.search = search;

// Line ~215
const query: any = { search }; // ❌ Using 'any'
if (search) query.search = search;

// Line ~365
const query: any = { page, limit }; // ❌ Using 'any'
if (search) query.search = search;

// Line ~395
const query: any = { search }; // ❌ Using 'any'
if (search) query.search = search;
```

**Rekomendasi:** Gunakan typed query:

```typescript
// Define type
interface FindManyQuery {
  page: number | string;
  limit?: number | string;
  search?: string;
}

// Use typed query
const query: FindManyQuery = { page, limit: appliedLimit };
if (search) query.search = search;
```

**Priority:** 🟡 Medium  
**Effort:** Low

---

#### **6. Error Message Tidak Konsisten**

**Lokasi:** Multiple places

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// Create posisi - Line ~180
toast.error("Terjadi kesalahan saat menambahkan posisi");

// Create pegawai - Line ~280
toast.error("Terjadi kesalahan saat menambahkan pegawai");

// Delete - Line ~430
toast.error("Terjadi kesalahan saat menghapus posisi organisasi");

// Edit - Line ~520
toast.error("Gagal memuat data");

// Update - Line ~560
toast.error("Gagal mengupdate posisi organisasi");
```

**Issue:**
- Generic error messages
- Inconsistent patterns ("Terjadi kesalahan" vs "Gagal")
- Tidak spesifik ke resource type

**Rekomendasi:** Standardisasi error messages:

```typescript
// Pattern: "[Action] [resource] gagal"
toast.error("Menambahkan Posisi Organisasi gagal");
toast.error("Menghapus Posisi Organisasi gagal");
toast.error("Memuat data Posisi Organisasi gagal");
toast.error("Memperbarui data Posisi Organisasi gagal");
```

**Priority:** 🟡 Low  
**Effort:** Low

---

#### **7. Zod Schema - Error Message Tidak Konsisten**

**Lokasi:** `src/app/admin/(dashboard)/_state/ppid/struktur_ppid/struktur_PPID.ts`

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// Line ~170
const templatePosisiOrganisasi = z.object({
  nama: z.string().min(1, "Nama harus diisi"), // ✅ OK
  deskripsi: z.string().optional(), // ⚠️ No min message
  hierarki: z.number().int().positive("Hierarki harus angka positif"), // ✅ OK
});

// Line ~450
const templatePegawai = z.object({
  namaLengkap: z.string().min(1, "Nama wajib diisi"), // ✅ OK
  gelarAkademik: z.string().min(1, "Gelar Akademik wajib diisi"), // ✅ OK
  imageId: z.string().min(1, "Gambar wajib dipilih"), // ✅ OK
  tanggalMasuk: z.string().min(1, "Tanggal masuk wajib diisi"), // ✅ OK
  email: z.string().email("Email tidak valid").optional(), // ⚠️ Optional tapi ada validation
  telepon: z.string().min(1, "Telepom wajib diisi"), // ❌ Typo: "Telepom"
  alamat: z.string().min(1, "Alamat wajib diisi"), // ✅ OK
  posisiId: z.string().min(1, "Posisi wajib diisi"), // ✅ OK
  isActive: z.boolean().default(true), // ✅ OK
});
```

**Rekomendasi:** Fix typo dan standardisasi:

```typescript
const templatePegawai = z.object({
  namaLengkap: z.string().min(1, "Nama lengkap wajib diisi"),
  gelarAkademik: z.string().min(1, "Gelar akademik wajib diisi"),
  imageId: z.string().min(1, "Foto profil wajib diunggah"),
  tanggalMasuk: z.string().min(1, "Tanggal masuk wajib diisi"),
  email: z.string().email("Format email tidak valid").optional().or(z.literal('')),
  telepon: z.string().min(1, "Nomor telepon wajib diisi"), // ✅ Fix typo
  alamat: z.string().min(1, "Alamat wajib diisi"),
  posisiId: z.string().min(1, "Posisi wajib dipilih"),
  isActive: z.boolean().default(true),
});
```

**Priority:** 🟡 Low  
**Effort:** Low

---

### **🟢 LOW (Minor Polish)**

#### **8. Pagination onChange Tidak Include Search**

**Lokasi:** `pegawai/page.tsx`

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// Line ~170
<Pagination
  value={page}
  onChange={(newPage) => {
    load(newPage, 10);  // ⚠️ Missing search parameter
    window.scrollTo(0, 0);
  }}
  total={totalPages}
  // ...
/>
```

**Issue:** Saat ganti page, search query hilang.

**Rekomendasi:** Include search:
```typescript
onChange={(newPage) => {
  load(newPage, 10, debouncedSearch);  // ✅ Include search
  window.scrollTo(0, 0);
}}
```

**Priority:** 🟢 Low  
**Effort:** Low

---

#### **9. Missing Loading State di Submit Button**

**Lokasi:** `pegawai/create/page.tsx`, `pegawai/[id]/edit/page.tsx`

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// create/page.tsx - Line ~240
<Button
  onClick={handleSubmit}
  radius="md"
  size="md"
  disabled={!isFormValid() || isSubmitting}
  // ...
>
  {isSubmitting ? <Loader size="sm" color="white" /> : 'Simpan'}
</Button>
```

**Issue:** Button tidak check `stateOrganisasi.create.loading` dari global state.

**Rekomendasi:** Check both states:
```typescript
disabled={!isFormValid() || isSubmitting || stateOrganisasi.create.loading}
{isSubmitting || stateOrganisasi.create.loading ? (
  <Loader size="sm" color="white" />
) : (
  'Simpan'
)}
```

**Priority:** 🟢 Low  
**Effort:** Low

---

#### **10. Duplicate Error Logging**

**Lokasi:** Multiple files

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// edit/page.tsx - Line ~120
} catch (error) {
  console.error('Error loading pegawai:', error); // ❌ Duplicate
  toast.error(error instanceof Error ? error.message : 'Gagal memperbarui data pegawai');
}

// edit/page.tsx - Line ~160
} catch (error) {
  console.error('Error updating pegawai:', error); // ❌ Duplicate
  toast.error(error instanceof Error ? error.message : 'Gagal memperbarui data pegawai');
}
```

**Rekomendasi:** Cukup satu logging yang informatif:
```typescript
} catch (error) {
  console.error('Failed to load Pegawai:', err);
  toast.error('Gagal memuat data Pegawai');
}
```

**Priority:** 🟢 Low  
**Effort:** Low

---

#### **11. Button Label Inconsistency**

**Lokasi:** Multiple files

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// create/page.tsx - Line ~230
<Button ...>Reset</Button>

// edit/page.tsx - Line ~140
<Button ...>Batal</Button>

// Should be consistent: "Reset" atau "Batal"
```

**Rekomendasi:** Standardisasi:
```typescript
// Create: "Reset"
// Edit: "Batal" (lebih descriptive untuk cancel changes)
// OR both: "Reset" / "Batal"
```

**Priority:** 🟢 Low  
**Effort:** Low

---

#### **12. Search Placeholder Tidak Spesifik**

**Lokasi:** 
- `pegawai/page.tsx`: `placeholder='Cari nama pegawai atau posisi...'` ✅ Spesifik
- `posisi-organisasi/page.tsx`: `placeholder='Cari posisi organisasi...'` ✅ OK

**Verdict:** ✅ **SUDAH BENAR** - Placeholder sudah spesifik.

**Priority:** 🟢 None  
**Effort:** None

---

#### **13. Non-Active Endpoint Method**

**Lokasi:** `src/app/admin/(dashboard)/_state/ppid/struktur_ppid/struktur_PPID.ts`

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// Line ~490
nonActive: {
  loading: false,
  async byId(id: string) {
    // ...
    const res = await fetch(`/api/ppid/strukturppid/pegawai/non-active/${id}`, {
      method: "DELETE", // ⚠️ Biasanya nonActive pakai PATCH atau PUT
    });
    // ...
  },
}
```

**Issue:** Method "DELETE" untuk non-active agak confusing. Biasanya pakai "PATCH" atau "PUT".

**Rekomendasi:** Consider using PATCH:
```typescript
const res = await fetch(`/api/ppid/strukturppid/pegawai/non-active/${id}`, {
  method: "PATCH",  // ✅ More semantic for toggle active/inactive
  headers: { "Content-Type": "application/json" },
  body: JSON.stringify({ isActive: false }),
});
```

**Priority:** 🟢 Low  
**Effort:** Low (perlu update API juga)

---

#### **14. OrganizationChart - Missing Expand/Collapse Controls**

**Lokasi:** `struktur-organisasi/page.tsx`

**Masalah:**
```typescript
// Line ~80
<OrganizationChart value={chartData} nodeTemplate={nodeTemplate} />
```

**Issue:** Tidak ada controls untuk expand/collapse all nodes.

**Rekomendasi:** Add toggle button:
```typescript
const [expanded, setExpanded] = useState(true);

const toggleAll = () => {
  const newExpanded = !expanded;
  setExpanded(newExpanded);
  // Update chartData dengan expanded: newExpanded untuk semua nodes
};

return (
  <Box>
    <Group justify="flex-end" mb="md">
      <Button size="xs" onClick={toggleAll}>
        {expanded ? 'Collapse All' : 'Expand All'}
      </Button>
    </Group>
    <OrganizationChart value={chartData} nodeTemplate={nodeTemplate} />
  </Box>
);
```

**Priority:** 🟢 Low  
**Effort:** Low

---

## 📋 RINGKASAN ACTION ITEMS

| Priority | Issue | Module | Impact | Effort | Status |
|----------|-------|--------|--------|--------|--------|
| 🔴 P0 | **Schema missing deletedAt** | Schema | **HIGH** | Medium | **MUST FIX** |
| 🔴 P0 | Fetch method inconsistency | State | Medium | Medium | Perlu refactor |
| 🔴 P1 | **HTML injection risk** | UI | **HIGH (Security)** | Low | **Should fix** |
| 🟡 M | Console.log in production | State | Low | Low | Optional |
| 🟡 M | Type safety (any usage) | State | Low | Low | Optional |
| 🟡 M | Error message inconsistency | State/UI | Low | Low | Optional |
| 🟡 M | Zod schema typo ("Telepom") | State | Low | Low | Should fix |
| 🟢 L | Pagination missing search param | Pegawai UI | Low | Low | Should fix |
| 🟢 L | Missing loading state di submit button | UI | Low | Low | Optional |
| 🟢 L | Duplicate error logging | UI | Low | Low | Optional |
| 🟢 L | Button label inconsistency | UI | Low | Low | Optional |
| 🟢 L | Non-active endpoint method | API | Low | Low | Optional |
| 🟢 L | OrganizationChart expand/collapse controls | UI | Low | Low | Nice to have |

---

## ✅ KESIMPULAN

### **Overall Quality: 🟢 BAIK (8/10)**

**Strengths:**
1. ✅ **Organization Chart** - Unique visual hierarchy feature (EXCELLENT!)
2. ✅ UI/UX clean & responsive
3. ✅ File upload handling solid
4. ✅ Form validation comprehensive (email validation, required fields)
5. ✅ State management terstruktur (Valtio)
6. ✅ **Edit form reset sudah benar** (original data tracking)
7. ✅ **Active/Non-active toggle** untuk pegawai
8. ✅ Loading state management dengan finally block
9. ✅ findManyAll untuk organization chart data

**Critical Issues:**
1. ⚠️ **Schema missing deletedAt** - Inconsistency dengan StrukturOrganisasiPPID (HIGH)
2. ⚠️ Fetch method pattern inconsistency (ApiFetch vs fetch manual)
3. ⚠️ **HTML injection risk** di deskripsi posisi (HIGH Security)

**Areas for Improvement:**
1. ⚠️ **Add deletedAt field** ke PosisiOrganisasiPPID dan PegawaiPPID
2. ⚠️ **Refactor fetch methods** untuk gunakan ApiFetch consistently
3. ⚠️ **Fix HTML injection** dengan DOMPurify atau backend validation
4. ⚠️ **Fix typo** "Telepom" → "Telepon" di Zod schema
5. ⚠️ **Improve type safety** dengan remove `any` usage

**Recommended Next Steps:**
1. **🔴 CRITICAL: Add schema deletedAt** - 30 menit (perlu migration)
2. **🔴 HIGH: Fix HTML injection** dengan DOMPurify - 30 menit
3. **🔴 HIGH: Refactor fetch methods** ke ApiFetch - 1 jam
4. **🟡 MEDIUM: Fix typo** di Zod schema - 5 menit
5. **🟢 LOW: Add pagination search param** - 10 menit
6. **🟢 LOW: Polish minor issues** - 30 menit

---

## 📈 COMPARISON WITH OTHER MODULES

| Module | Unique Features | Schema | State | Edit Reset | Overall |
|--------|----------------|--------|-------|------------|---------|
| Profil | ❌ None | ✅ Good | ⚠️ Good | ✅ Good | 🟢 |
| Desa Anti Korupsi | ❌ None | ⚠️ deletedAt | ⚠️ Good | ✅ Good | 🟢 |
| SDGs Desa | ❌ None | ⚠️ deletedAt | ⚠️ Good | ✅ Good | 🟢 |
| APBDes | ✅ Dual upload, Items hierarchy | ✅ **Best** | ⚠️ Good | ✅ Good | 🟢 |
| Prestasi Desa | ❌ None | ⚠️ deletedAt | ⚠️ Good | ✅ Good | 🟢 |
| PPID Profil | ✅ Rich Text, Modular forms | ⚠️ deletedAt | ✅ **Best** | ✅ **Excellent** | 🟢⭐ |
| **Struktur PPID** | ✅ **Org Chart**, Hierarchy, Non-active | ⚠️ Inconsistent | ✅ Good | ✅ Good | 🟢 |

**Struktur PPID Highlights:**
- ✅ **UNIQUE:** Organization Chart visualization (no other module has this!)
- ✅ **UNIQUE:** Hierarchical position structure (parent-child)
- ✅ **UNIQUE:** Active/Non-active toggle feature
- ✅ **GOOD:** Email validation dengan regex
- ⚠️ **ISSUE:** Schema inconsistency (deletedAt missing di 2 models)

---

## 🎯 UNIQUE FEATURES OF STRUKTUR PPID MODULE

**Most Unique Module:**
1. ✅ **PrimeReact OrganizationChart** - Visual tree hierarchy (UNIQUE!)
2. ✅ **Parent-child position relationships** - Hierarchical structure
3. ✅ **Active/Non-active toggle** - Soft disable tanpa delete
4. ✅ **Email validation** - Regex validation untuk email format
5. ✅ **findManyAll pattern** - Load all data untuk organization chart

**Best Practices:**
1. ✅ Organization chart implementation excellent
2. ✅ Loading state management proper (dengan finally block)
3. ✅ Edit form reset comprehensive (original data tracking)
4. ✅ Email validation di form (create & edit)
5. ✅ Date input handling untuk tanggal masuk

**Critical Issues:**
1. ❌ **Schema deletedAt missing** - Inconsistency issue
2. ❌ **HTML injection risk** - Same issue as modul lain dengan rich text

---

**Catatan:** Secara keseluruhan, modul **Struktur PPID adalah YANG PALING UNIQUE** dengan Organization Chart visualization yang excellent. Module ini punya fitur-fitur yang tidak ada di modul lain (hierarchical positions, org chart, active/non-active toggle).

**Unique Strengths:**
1. ✅ **Organization Chart** - Best visual representation
2. ✅ **Hierarchical data structure** - Parent-child relationships
3. ✅ **Active/Non-active feature** - Soft disable tanpa delete
4. ✅ **Email validation** - Comprehensive form validation

**Priority Action:**
```diff
🔴 FIX INI SEKARANG (30 MENIT + MIGRATION):
File: prisma/schema.prisma
Line: 327-332, 343-351

model PosisiOrganisasiPPID {
  // ...
  isActive   Boolean    @default(true)
  createdAt  DateTime   @default(now())
  updatedAt  DateTime   @updatedAt
+ deletedAt  DateTime?  @default(null)  // ✅ Add for soft delete
}

model PegawaiPPID {
  // ...
  isActive   Boolean    @default(true)
  createdAt  DateTime   @default(now())
  updatedAt  DateTime   @updatedAt
+ deletedAt  DateTime?  @default(null)  // ✅ Add for soft delete
}

# Lalu jalankan:
bunx prisma db push
# atau
bunx prisma migrate dev --name add_deletedat_struktur_ppid
```

```diff
🔴 FIX HTML INJECTION (30 MENIT):
File: posisi-organisasi/page.tsx
+ import DOMPurify from 'dompurify';

// Line ~95
- dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: item.deskripsi || '-' }}
+ dangerouslySetInnerHTML={{ __html: DOMPurify.sanitize(item.deskripsi) }}

// Repeat for mobile view line ~155
```

Setelah fix critical issues, module ini **PRODUCTION-READY** dan **ORGANIZATION CHART** adalah fitur yang bisa jadi **SHOWCASE**! 🎉

---

**File Location:** `QC/PPID/QC-STRUKTUR-PPID-MODULE.md` 📄
